ORDER ONLINE
See MENU & ORDER
Welcome to Bay34th St Pizzeria. Your search for authentic NY style pizza in Dallas ends here.
What makes Bay34th pizzas special is the fact that we make our dough daily from scratch, we use freshest produce and all our toppings are 100% beef and turkey products.
The father & Son duo – Asip & Gezim Asani, their mantra is to provide customers unique dining experiences – quality food, pleasant ambiance and exceptional customer service. You can see them on the restaurant floor most of the times, please reach out to them if you have any concerns, compliments or if you want to say hi to them.
Welcome to Bay34th St Pizzeria. Your search for authentic NY style pizza in Dallas ends here.
What makes Bay34th pizzas special is the fact that we make our dough daily from scratch, we use freshest produce and all our toppings are 100% beef and turkey products.
The father & Son duo – Asip & Gezim Asani, their mantra is to provide customers unique dining experiences – quality food, pleasant ambiance and exceptional customer service. You can see them on the restaurant floor most of the times, please reach out to them if you have any concerns, compliments or if you want to say hi to them.
Check out our
Brooklyn Stuffed Pizza! - $26.95
Large size only. Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, meatballs, onions, peppers, sauce and mozzarella.
EXPLORE MORE
Customers' Pick: Listen to Their Feedback About Us!
“My friends and I were craving some pizza and we didn’t want any chain pizza restaurants. The first place that popped up was Bay34th Street Pizzeria and we were IMPRESSED. We loved the pizza, the amazing service, and ambiance. We got a whole 18 inch half cheese half pepperoni pizza which fed 3 people pretty well. We also got a homemade cannoli which we would rate 8/10. There was a little too much powdered sugar for our taste, but if you love powdered sugar it is amazing! If you are looking for NY style pizza, come here :) You will not regret it!”
By - Lance Tran-
“I was born and raised in Staten Island so when I moved to Dallas one of the hardest thing I gave up was pizza until now! I’m glad I found you guys! Finally a genuine New York slice! If you’re from NYC like me a miss real pizza this place is worth it! I’ll definitely be coming back regularly! The only thing I suggest is maybe a adding a little more cheese on your regular pie (but that might just be a personal preference) other that I’m very happy!!”
By - Nicholas Debari -
“Fist time my daughter & I tried this pizza spot. Great friendly atmosphere, pizza was delicious and filling. We got the Brooklyn stuffed pizza, it comes in one size, so this is definitely a family size pizza with large slices. No pork here, all beef & turkey based meats. They didn't skimp at all. We will definitely come back😊”
By - Cara Mel 
"The pizza was amazing for a very decent price. I got two slices that looked the size of a medium pizza put together. The bottom had a nice crunch to it even though it wasn't a super thick crust. Plus the flavors were very balanced. My 3 year old are his entire pizza which is rare for him."
Write your caption hereBy - Ashley Herring-
"For my order all was so good and the pizza was delivered on time. My only concern was witnessing a Spanish speaking patron not feeling they could order when the menu had lots of pictures and no offer to help was given. They were going to walk out if I hadn't offered to translate. Do better. Everyone deserves the dignity to be served. Thank you. 😊"
Write your caption hereBy - Cynthia Garza -
"Man...listen. I'm not a person that often writes reviews, good or bad.... but I feel like I was lied to and I have to correct it. Someone told me this pizza was good,they lied.....This pizza is amazing! It was fresh with the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. They found the perfect meeting place that we all like, between soft and crisp. I recommend that anytime you're going to eat food, you eat this pizza. I know this might seem like a bit much but if you're a foodie like me, you know how it is when you find something you love. This place made me fall in love with pizza again!"
Write your caption hereBy - Dre Pearson -
"This place has amazing pizza! We have visited twice in the week we have been in Texas. We've tried the pepperoni, the spinach, ricotta, and mozzarella pizza, and the vegetarian. All had the most amazing crust and sweet sauce. The balance of ingredients were excellent too. The spinach pizza actually had olive oil instead of sauce and it was great. They offer a variety of desserts; we had the chocolate cake and it was good. You can buy whole pizzas or slices which is really convenient. The prices are fair, the service amazing, and they deliver too!"
Write your caption hereBy - Dania Ramirez
-
“My friends and I were craving some pizza and we didn’t want any chain pizza restaurants. The first place that popped up was Bay34th Street Pizzeria and we were IMPRESSED. We loved the pizza, the amazing service, and ambiance. We got a whole 18 inch half cheese half pepperoni pizza which fed 3 people pretty well. We also got a homemade cannoli which we would rate 8/10. There was a little too much powdered sugar for our taste, but if you love powdered sugar it is amazing! If you are looking for NY style pizza, come here :) You will not regret it!”
By - Lance Tran -
“I was born and raised in Staten Island so when I moved to Dallas one of the hardest thing I gave up was pizza until now! I’m glad I found you guys! Finally a genuine New York slice! If you’re from NYC like me a miss real pizza this place is worth it! I’ll definitely be coming back regularly! The only thing I suggest is maybe a adding a little more cheese on your regular pie (but that might just be a personal preference) other that I’m very happy!!”
By - Nicholas Debari -
“Fist time my daughter & I tried this pizza spot. Great friendly atmosphere, pizza was delicious and filling. We got the Brooklyn stuffed pizza, it comes in one size, so this is definitely a family size pizza with large slices. No pork here, all beef & turkey based meats. They didn't skimp at all. We will definitely come back😊”
By - Cara Mel 
"The pizza was amazing for a very decent price. I got two slices that looked the size of a medium pizza put together. The bottom had a nice crunch to it even though it wasn't a super thick crust. Plus the flavors were very balanced. My 3 year old are his entire pizza which is rare for him."
Write your caption hereBy - Ashley Herring-
"For my order all was so good and the pizza was delivered on time. My only concern was witnessing a Spanish speaking patron not feeling they could order when the menu had lots of pictures and no offer to help was given. They were going to walk out if I hadn't offered to translate. Do better. Everyone deserves the dignity to be served. Thank you. 😊"
Write your caption hereBy - Cynthia Garza -
"Man...listen. I'm not a person that often writes reviews, good or bad.... but I feel like I was lied to and I have to correct it. Someone told me this pizza was good,they lied.....This pizza is amazing! It was fresh with the perfect amount of cheese and toppings. They found the perfect meeting place that we all like, between soft and crisp. I recommend that anytime you're going to eat food, you eat this pizza. I know this might seem like a bit much but if you're a foodie like me, you know how it is when you find something you love. This place made me fall in love with pizza again!"
Write your caption hereBy - Dre Pearson -
"This place has amazing pizza! We have visited twice in the week we have been in Texas. We've tried the pepperoni, the spinach, ricotta, and mozzarella pizza, and the vegetarian. All had the most amazing crust and sweet sauce. The balance of ingredients were excellent too. The spinach pizza actually had olive oil instead of sauce and it was great. They offer a variety of desserts; we had the chocolate cake and it was good. You can buy whole pizzas or slices which is really convenient. The prices are fair, the service amazing, and they deliver too!"
Write your caption hereBy - Dania Ramirez
We are Open
MON-SUN
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
We are Open
MON - SUN
10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
